"What I'd like is to write for madmen-or for the angels" - Henry Miller, Nexus
Viser innlegg med etiketten words. Vis alle innlegg
Viser innlegg med etiketten words. Vis alle innlegg
tirsdag 20. august 2013
Deconstruction. Jolly good times spent with Derrida
Q: Explain and evaluate two or three key terms from
Derrida’s work (eg. Difference, the trace, the supplement, metaphysics of
presence, logocentrism, phonocentrism, intertextuality, deconstructions, etc.)
When reading Derrida, it is easy to confuse his philosophy
with the positions he is putting in to questions. He often quotes upon earlier
philosophers, and what I have found is that Derrida does this not as much to
provide evidence for his own philosophical claims, but more to tear apart other
philosophies. “Derrida always explains his philosophy through commentary on,
and discussions of, other work…”- Barry
Stocker,Derrida on Deconstruction, pp. 23
Derrida goes to
enormous trouble to reconstruct the positions of particular philosophical
classics. He is a part of the sceptical tradition. He defines his goals as
confronting the philosophical with the empirical in order to question the
philosophical.
If there is no-thing
outside the text, this implies, with the transformation of the concept of text
in general, that the text is no longer the snug air-tight inside of interiority
or an identity-to-itself ... but rather
a different placement of the effects of opening and closing. (Derrida 1981a,
35-6)
To understand Derrida’s views on language, we certainly need
to look at Saussure. For Saussure, no word is meaningful in itself, but only in
relation to other words. Thus, a word is meaningless without the entire
linguistic system to back it up. Derrida often quote upon Saussure and agreed
to some extend; the passages where Derrida finds the most positive aspects of
Saussure are to do with difference and the materiality of the signifier. For
Saussure, the system of language is not a form of imposed on an already existing
set of linguistic value, through its differences from other signs. A word does
not have a meaning: a definition must use other words. We can only define words
with other words and we can only separate words or signs from other words or
signs by reference to difference between words, not the essence within the
word. ‘Tree’ means tree because it does not mean any kind of animal object, it
does not mean any kind of fruit or vegetable, and so on. But for Derrida that
kind of argument already contains a disruption of metaphysical system that is
very apparent in Saussure. In Saussure, meaning can only be determined by the
differences between the material signifiers, so that we have what Derrida calls
an economy, in which it is the exchange and equivalence between different
linguistic values that determined meanings, not a structure that is
intrinsically metaphysical. He argues that words rely on what is not
immediately present for their meaning. Background context is crucial for
understanding. Hence, while this essay may mean something in this philosophical
discussion, it could well mean something else, say, and essay about global
warming. As Robert Miller explained in lecture, for you to fully understands
what I have written, you would have to know the entire context of why I am
writing, why you are reading, what our cultural understandings are, and so on,
hence; there is nothing outside the text.
At each step of understanding we take, the meaning is,
according to Derrida, updated and changes, deferred to a later time.
Unfortunately, later never comes, as when it does, it too will be superseded by
a further later.
Defining deconstruction is an activity that goes against the
whole thrust of Derrida’s thought. But let’s give it a go; it is in fact an
important part of Derrida’s philosophy, as well as the essay question. According to Derrida, all previous philosophy
is wrong, because each idea has been superseded. Our philosophy is also wrong,
because we too will be superseded. However we are prevented from rejecting
philosophy, because as soon we engage in it in any way, we are practising
philosophy. To understand this Derrida proposes ‘Deconstruction’, which is
impossible to define for reasons he himself has given. However, a very general
meaning of it can run as follows: deconstruction involves pulling apart
meanings, concepts, ideas, and the like, and examining and subverting the
foundations and assumptions on which they are based. Or more simply, it is
pulling an idea apart to get everything that it relies on for meaning.
Deconstruction however, can be deconstructed. Derrida
himself does this, which results in very circular arguments. This should not
been seen as a flaw in Derrida’s system, but an integral part of it. What this
does show is that there is no idea that cannot be subverted, examined, and
pulled apart. In much the same way as linguistic meaning, philosophical
certainty is impossible. Deconstruction often involves a way of reading that
concerns itself with decentring. According to Derrida, all western thought is
based on the idea of a centre; an origin, a truth, a fixed point, and the
issues with centres is that they try to exclude. In doing so they ignore,
repress or marginalize others, which becomes The Others. In a male dominated society the man is central (and
women is the marginalized other, repressed, ignored pushed to the margins, it
is also the same case when it comes to religions; if you have a Christ in the
centre of its icons the Christians will be central to that culture and
Buddhists, Muslims, Jews- anybody different will be in the margins-
marginalized pushed to the outside. Deconstruction is a tactic of decentring, a
way of reading, which first makes us aware of the centrality of the central
term, and then it attempts subvert the central term so that the marginalized
term can become central. Derrida claims that deconstruction is a political
practice and that one must not pass over and neutralize this phase of
subversion too quickly. For this phase of reversal is needed in order to
subvert the original hierarchy of the first term over the second. But
eventually, one must realize that this new hierarchy is equally unstable, and
surrender to the complete free play of the binary opposites in a no hierarchy
way. Then you see that both readings and many others are equally possible.
Derrida’s ideas about language and his deconstruction
theory, seemed to me at first way to complex an extremely hard to grasp, but
after close reading bits and pieces of his texts and others critique on him, I
definitely understood more about where he is coming from. It all seem very
complex though, but where he states that nothing can really be understood
without by the use of words and language, an what we cannot put words on,
define and interpret without language, is not known, there might be a lot
outside of text, but we won’t understand or know what it exactly is before we
can define it with the use of words, words that might never come clear to any
of us. It reminds me of that feeling one gets at times, a strange feeling
within, you can’t seem to put words on it, explain it, and neither you nor
anybody else will be able to understand the feeling you have within. It also
resemblance the phrase; the more you learn, the more you see how little you
actually know. You will be going on for eternity trying to explain words upon
words, but not being able to come up with a final solution, a final word or
explanation. You will never be able to know everything, the whole context of
any words, languages, texts, things, animals or human beings. It might sound a
bit depressing, but I think that is the beauty of it; the mystery. There is
some strange kind of beauty in Derrida’s deconstruction theory as well, the
fact that it is somehow necessary to pull apart these cultural, religious
centres, to make room for others who has been pushed aside for too long. In
Barry Stocker’s Derrida on Deconstruction
he is saying that Derrida claimed himself to be somewhat of a radical , and
being an ex-socialist (if I can ever put that way) I completely fell for his
idea of decentring. The only problem is that once you’ve decentred something,
the other will take its place and become the centre, so you would be going
around in circles, and not really resolving anything. It sounds good in theory,
but wouldn’t necessarily work as well in real life. Perhaps a bit similar to
communism.
I would love to continue to explain and try to define
Derrida’s ideas, but if I did, I would be going on for the entire eternity;
there is not such a thing as a final word.
RESOURCES.
·
Derrida on
Deconstruction; Barry Stocker; Routledge Philosophy Guidebook
·
Ethics,politics,subjectivity;
Simon Critchley; Verso,1999
·
Interview:
Jacques Derrida
Author(s): G. Scarpetta, J. L. Houdebine
and Jacques Derrida
Source: Diacritics, Vol. 2, No. 4 (Winter,
1972), pp. 35-43Published by: The Johns Hopkins University PressStable URL:
http://www.jstor.org/stable/464504 .
·
At the
Intersection: Kant, Derrida, and the Relation between Ethics and Politics
Author(s): Marguerite La Caze):Source:
Political Theory, Vol. 35, No. 6 (Dec., 2007), pp. 781-805Published by: Sage
Publications, Inc.Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/20452600 .
·
Document
Phil1087 No.8 2010; Robert Miller
Professional Writing.
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Media Release
21/09-2012
Earlier today Federal Environment Minister Brear announced
the protections and the concessions of the Waraki heritage. 50,000 hectares of
the area will be protected and listed on the National Heritage Listing, whilst
20,000 hectares are to be opened for two new mines.
The Waraki in the north-western area corner of Tasmania has
been a mining magnet over the last few years. It has to some extend helped the
state's economy. But today's results show that our state's economy is in
recession.
Federal Environment minister Celeste Brear value the Waraki
heritage,but see one solution to how we can get in on the mining boom that the
rest of the states have access to, and to be able to receive some economic
growth. The Waraki area covers around 450,000 hectares.Even though most of the
area are designated conservation areas and national park ,70,000 of these
hectares belong to the Sate Forest, which means that they are available for
mining and logging.
Conservation groups have recognised the areas value and all
its wilderness so due to requests it has been decided that the whole area is to
be given to National Heritage Listing, except for 20,000 hectares which will be
opened to two new mines. These two mines will be the Sinelco Tin Mine and the
Cinto Gold mine.
"We do value the land and heritage of the Waraki, but
the need of economic growth needs to be considered as well." Federal
Environmental Minister Brear announced, and continues;
'the Federal Government can also see economic benefits in
protecting the rest of the Waraki and they will create a new category of
environmental business grants that will be open to eco-tourism operators in
Waraki"
The Nationl Heritage Listing of the rest of the Waraki comes
in preparation for a Federal Government application to UNESCO for the Waraki to
get International World Heritage Listing. The Federal Government will submit
this application to the United States in November.
Professional Writing
Down the narrow alleyway I stumble, and enter the alluring
entrance to the basement; the magnificent, dark, noisy and often smelly
basement. A basement I sometimes might as well could call home.
I would be considered pretty darn lucky. I moved across the
world with a tiny suitcase to start a new journey in a new and intriguing city.
I left my family, friends and my dear sewing machine back in Norway. I knew
coming to Melbourne meant a fresh start, not that I desperately needed one. I
love my friends, and nothing can replace my family (nor can any sewing machine
on this planet replace my old Husqvarna), I was excited and scared to shit. I
knew I had to make new friends. I hate socialising with new people. But
somehow, it changed, or I changed. I made new friends and I even stuck it
through with a guy whom is now my boyfriend. And that’s when my journey really
started, my journey down the narrow alleyway and through the alluring entrance
to the dark and smelly basement. This basement is my second home.
My proper home is a lovely two bedroom house with a backyard
in Carlton North, shared between me, my love and my best friend. I love our
home, and I love both my house-mates, and I am extremely lucky to be able to
live with them instead of all the other gumtree creeps I've previously shared
residencies with. We have a jolly good
time together. But, my inner introvert is never to be allowed to show his/her
face when I am at home. You see, it brings a great deal of lousy atmosphere.
“Yes, I am being a sook!”
As a result; a
stumble down the narrow alleyway and enter the basement. Usually I tell them
I'm making my way down to bring my love some food, which I do. (You see, my
love is the barman in the basement). But it is just a ridiculous excuse. It
more or less because I get to order myself a Jameson & coke when my love is
full and content, and I make my way to my favourite corner, gaze at the people
and let my mind unwind, I let my brain have a breather, I become a vegetable.
Not physically of course, I still need to use my hand to tip the short-drink in
to my mouth!
My love often ask me if I am shy; “do you not like hanging
out with a big group of people?” I don’t really say much when I am with a big
group, they all seem loud and too eager to let everyone know what happened on
the tram on the way over or how delicious the burrito they had for lunch was, I
don’t want to take that away from them. I know most of the hard working
bartenders in the basement, they often come over; “are you sitting here by
yourself?” And then they give me a look
which screams ‘I pity her’, or ‘you are a tad odd and awkward’ look. I am not
really odd or awkward, but sometimes you need to get out of the house and down
the dirty and smelly basement to get some alone time! And if you can get some
alone time with a drink in your hand, you've hit the jackpot!
Will To Power.
Anything that is living and a dying body, will have to be incarnate 'will to power.' It will strive to grow, spread, seize, become predominant- not from any morality or immorality, but because it is living and because life simply is will-to-power. Exploitation belongs to the essence of what lives, as a basic organic function, it is a consequence of the will-to-power, which is after all will-to-life.From the 1890's the philosopher F. Nietzsche exerted a profound and enduring impact on society, he reckoned he could provide a persuasive account on e.g religion, science & philosophy. Nietzsche was not a typical happy chap, he did not at all have a positive view on life and it's challenges and felt rather sickened about his life on plant earth, and so should any other sensitive and honestly aware person be. And therein lies a great danger, Nietzsche felt. If we get sickened by life by looking at it in it's true colours, which we should,otherwise we would be deceiving ourselves, seeking comfort in imaginary religious ideas, wishful thoughts etc.
So, Nietzsche thought; we have to change our values, change from being weak, decadent, soft-hearted, sentimental and timid, to having courageous, self-assertive, risk taking, achievement taking obstacle overcoming values. We are going to have to become the type of person who relishes playing hard ball with life for our own self-created causes.
Therefore, Nietzsche introduced the hypothesis; that nature in essence is nothing but will-to-power. The will-to-power describes what Nietzsche may have believed to be the main driving force in man: achievement, ambition, the striving to reach the highest possible position in life. Will-to-power is an explanation for all human behaviour. It is an impulse, conscious or unconscious, to become superior or dominant over other people, aspects or objects in order to distinguish yourself.
Robert M mentioned in lecture 'that every moral act the is always a feeling of self-satisfaction, an awareness that one is good, righteous and superior to the bad. You would argue that when Susan B Anthony, the American civil rights leader fought for women rights in the 1800's did it to gain equal rights between men and women, to help her fellow women in suffrage, not to gain power and feel superior to anybody else. You would also instantly argue that Maximus Gullermo Manus and his comrades in the Norwegian resistance movement, who were risking to get exposed by Gestapo and their lives , by sabotaging against the Nazi's during WW2, did it for peoples freedom and peoples rights. and every other war-hero that died on the battlefield, fighting for their countries freedom. But according to Nietzsche, is is the contrary; self-sacrificing for their cause or truth is still in accordance to will-to-power.
Will-to-power work by self-depiction. The martyrs get a great feeling of power via their belief that they were in the right. It gives them a sense of superiority, the society would also put them higher than themselves, and give their heroes superiority.
Nietzsche then goes on discussing the 'innocence of becoming.; he rejects the idea that the weak and weary are in such a condition because of the long period of domination and oppression they have endured at the hands of the ruling classes. The blaming of others for the conditions that one happens to be in is nothing more than finding a scapegoat. People need to find others responsible for their miserable condition because they don't want to feel as though there is no reason that they are what they are.
Nietzsche sees this idea as a product of the priestly class, who wanted to invent a right for themselves to take revenge upon those who were their oppressor. in other words responsibility for one's station in life and one's actions is a product of the revenge and ressentiment of those in a state of subjugation. The fact of matter, as Nietzsche claims, is that no-one is responsible for the situation into which a person finds oneself born, or th qualities that a person has: 'that no one has given man his qualities,neither God, nor Society, nor his parents and ancestors, nor he himself....that no one is to be held responsible for the fact that anyone exists at all....'- Nietzsche; The Will to Power, ibid pp 402
The innocence to becoming is the idea that all existence is innocent. To hold someone or something responsible for one's happen-to-be condition is merely to make sour grapes out of those who find themselves in a more favourable circumstances.
Did Nietzsche manage to debunk traditional religion, morality, and philosophical claims by providing us with the will-to-power hypothesis? Nietzsche contributes to the sociological discussion on for example culture, theory and being . He highlights how much of humans are being socially conditioned. His dislikes for sociology is clear, he argues that instead of there being positive effect on mankind, these sociologists of the future will produce a weakening and impoverishment on mankind.
Patrick Asper explains that 'one can divide Nietzsche's argumentation into three parts: (1) an explanation of how values emerge, (2) an explanation of how values emerge and (3) a normative critique of values.
By using this form we manage to expose the pattern which makes Nietzsche's arguments even more powerful.
Personally, I believe Nietzsche debunked the traditional way of thinking, maybe it is because I do think people are in accordance to will-to-power. There is always a deeper meaning why we do what we do.
But as discussed in class, there can be different levels of will-to-power, even though you still get a feeling of being in the right when doing something good, the difference lies in how you benefit from it.
a few preparations in advanced.
'I want to be a writer when I grow up' she wrote in her daisy and horse covered diary.
It was as clear as the bright blue sky, and to this day, it still is. I am going to have to purchase myself one of those old fashioned typewriters to start off with; I am not the kind of gal who embrace new technology. I don't fancy typing on fancy thingys, whatever they might be. Besides computer screens tends to pay back with headaches for the quality time I offer.
I wouldn't mind a deliciously leather scented A4 sized journal accompanied with a smooth scrolling pen if it weren't for the wrist pains.
With this typewriter I would write all sorts of works; perhaps a memoir of my lost granddad( he was awesome), a personal opinionated article or perhaps a opening for a novel named Steve.
The one downside by using a typewriter would be the future paperwork, all the organising. I would need to get my hands on a metal archive drawer, which would have to be organised alphabetically in advance.
It sounds swell.... almost romantic. Finally things will be in order for me to spew out meaningful and powerful words that would baffle by few, yet supportive readers.
It was as clear as the bright blue sky, and to this day, it still is. I am going to have to purchase myself one of those old fashioned typewriters to start off with; I am not the kind of gal who embrace new technology. I don't fancy typing on fancy thingys, whatever they might be. Besides computer screens tends to pay back with headaches for the quality time I offer.
I wouldn't mind a deliciously leather scented A4 sized journal accompanied with a smooth scrolling pen if it weren't for the wrist pains.
With this typewriter I would write all sorts of works; perhaps a memoir of my lost granddad( he was awesome), a personal opinionated article or perhaps a opening for a novel named Steve.
The one downside by using a typewriter would be the future paperwork, all the organising. I would need to get my hands on a metal archive drawer, which would have to be organised alphabetically in advance.
It sounds swell.... almost romantic. Finally things will be in order for me to spew out meaningful and powerful words that would baffle by few, yet supportive readers.
Abonner på:
Innlegg (Atom)